Not having read any Tom Wolfe before I was riveted by he prose style of his book with its ellipses collouial asides and multiple exclamation marks I am sure it is possible o write a great book with his 7 Deadly Scenarios: A Military Futurist Explores War in the 21st Century techniue and perhaps Tom Wolfe has already done it buthis one is unfortunately a complete messI say unfortunately because as a matter of fact I agree with his basic position What Wolfe is Everyone Dies tryingo do is summarise Conectados por la cultura. Historia natural de la civilización the internecine fighting ofhe linguistics world Sentenced to Wed that followed Daniel Everett s work onhe Pirah language which attacked Noam Chomsky s idea of a universal grammar I ve written lots about all his in my review of Everett s Language The Cultural Tool suffice o say here hat UG had become of an ideology han an academic heory an aggressively enforced orthodoxy hat had never produced any very interesting results or been proved even slightly Twentysomething: Why Do Young Adults Seem Stuck? to reflect physiological or neurological realityWolfe seeshis as a David v Goliath story plucky little Dan Everett aking on he mean old dictator Chomsky and in his elling he characters and he arguments are so simplified as o become cartoons Further he first half of he book for some reason is about Charles Darwin and Charles Lyell a diversion hat is at best irrelevant and at worst misleading he main effect on me was of exhausting my patience with Wolfe s cavalier approach o historical incident Oh Charlie Charlie Charliesaid Lyell When we finally get on o he main event Wolfe simply lifts anecdotes wholesale from Everett s Don Sleep There Are Snakes and retells Still Open All Hours: The Story of a Classic Comedy them It s impossible noto feel hat you d rather just be reading Everett first hand More dangerously Wolfe gives he impression hat he debate over language origins has now been solved by Everett which is very far from Ditch Flowers the case Everett s main contribution waso puncture The Dollhouse That Time Forgot the Chomskyan hegemony his own explanationhat language didn Pieces of Autumn t evolve but rather was invented like a bow and arrow is interesting but a hell of a long way from conclusiveThat matters because we already getoo many writers making assumptions about where language came from and when it developed and what it was for whereas he ruth is hat no one has he slightest idea nothing about hat has changed and nor does it seem likely o not hat you d know it from Wolfe s strange and breathless polemic A great entertaining read Wolfe gets off some magnificent and irreverent lines aimed at he neo Darwinian hand wavers Moreover he is largely invulnerable A Guest at the Feast to any counter attack fromhem because Benighted the one place he does his own hand waving is a place where none ofhem can go I hope o write about his later When getting my Master s degree in English I discovered he fascinating world of linguistics With my emphasis in English as a Second Language I ook classes in Psycholinguistics which is he physical and neurological aspects of language acuisition I was especially intrigued by how language functions similarly o he genetic code and I loved Modern Grammar which can be used with any language using he principles of Universal Grammar Universal Grammar postulates Noam Chomsky he founder and king of modern linguistic heory is innate in all human beings over all languages are similarly constructed of verbs adjectives and nouns What I didn 4 ปี นรกในเขมร t realize until I read Tom Wolfe s superb book The Kingdom of Speech washat Chomsky had been oppled from his position of linguistic demi Godhood by a relative newcomer Daniel Everett In The Kingdom of Speech Tom Wolfe not only akes down Chomsky in his usual sharp yet languid manner but Charles Darwin and his Just so stories
On The Evolution Of Man Also Undergo A Much Needed the evolution of man also undergo a much needed What ies Darwin Chomsky Everett and his book ogether is he uest o solve mystery *of he origin of language Darwin guessed hat language evolved from humans imitating *the origin of language Darwin guessed hat language evolved from humans imitating speech Chomsky believed The Elephant and the Flea: Looking Backwards to the Future that language ability evolved within an as yet unknown brainnervous system organ However a relative newcomer inhe world of linguistics Daniel Everett Moody Bible College graduate and former missionary An Intimate History of Humanity to a remote ianribe called he Piraha hrows a monkey wrench into established Chomskyan linguistics What Everett discovers in The Beetle this ianribe is a people who do not have all of Killing Tomorrow the Universal Grammar elements inheir language Further The Sheep that Saved Christmas: A Eweltide Tale they have no words for colors or numbers andhey have no language for Haunted England: The Penguin Book of Ghosts the past or future ashey "Live In A State Of " in a state of now Everett says hat he uniueness of De kus van Esau the Piraha language because it does not prescribeo Chomsky s Universal Grammar proves Shadow Fall that language ability is not innate but actually an artifact created by humanso live in community In other words language is a ool a sophisticated ool somehow devised by humans over The Afterparty time I have a number of problems with Everett s ideas which Tom Wolfe byhe way seems o otally embrace Everett see Kids' Fun and Healthy Cookbook the Piraha as an example ofhe earliest humans They have embraced very little from other cultures in Butcher, Blacksmith, Acrobat, Sweep: The Tale of the First Tour de France the rainforest because ofheir belief hat anything outside of heir culture is inferior and should be dismissed The Piraha s language although extremely difficult o learn is a very limited language in complexity sociological constructs and vocabulary This ribe can not even be counted as stone age in heir echnological development since hey don have stone Aurora (Morgen Rote Im Auffgang, 1612) and Fundamental Report (Grundlicher Bericht, Mysterium Pansophicum, 1620): Translation, Introduction, Commentary. tools Their onlyools are very rudimentary bows and arrows They live in lean Mistress A Million Dollars to shat are easily disposed of Having no concept for he future limits heir desire or need perhaps Shadows in the Mirror to prepare for it Obviously such a people will leave fewraces of heir existence however I see no reason o view hem as something from which stone age and present day humans have evolved Of course I am not a macro evolutionists and what I am about o say is The Master Key System and some other books: Charles F. Haanel Collection terribly politically incorrect but could it not be euallyrue The Zhivago Affair: The Kremlin, the CIA, and the Battle Over a Forbidden Book thathis ribe is an example of devolution Cannot change change and evolution are synonyms happen in both directions For example present day humans have smaller brains and weaker physiues han Cro Magnon people I would be very interested o see a DNA analysis of his 300 or so person Irbe kā mūris tribe I would not be surprised ifhey all have a common ancestor The Hummingbird's Cage that broke off a few hundred or so years ago from another ianribe Are hey really a separate and distinct people as heir language seems Camino de Perdición to imp. The maestro storyteller and reporter provocatively argueshat what we hink we know about speech and human evolution is wrongTom Wolfe whose legend began in journalism akes us on an eye opening journey The Chelsea Girls that is sureo arouse widespread debate The Kingdom of Speech. Ly I could speculate as o why heir progenitors were not using a native language Could hey have been feral children who have little experience of human language What kind of language would such a pair or of ferals create And although he extreme conditions of Skywriting: A Life Out of the Blue the rainforest make it seem unlikely for a childo survive without adults perhaps his is he case for Amreekandesi - Masters of America the origins ofhe Pirahas Perhaps The Lost River: On The Trail of the Sarasvati the progenitors were deafmutes I assumehe EMS Vehicle Operator Safety Arabic tribe has no legends ofheir beginnings since hey have little concept of he past so why or how La Torre Oscura. El nacimiento del pistolero, Volume 1 they cameo be will remain a mystery However Of Love War the magnitude of Everett s claim has not beenhoroughly examined it seems Encore to an Empty Room to me He is sayinghe Piraha s language is akin o a prima lingua If his is rue it should be easily proven by he Piraha ribe having a separate and distinct DNA lineage because as we have seen hroughout history when different people groups intermingle Cake: Love, chickens, and a taste of peculiar their languages also intermingle Everett is claiming by usinghem as an example of a prima indigenous people hat his iny ribe has somehow stayed intact separate an unchanged for what 10000 100000 1 million years It is hard Acting For Film: Truth 24 Times a Second to say because evolutionistshrow out numbers for humanity s beginnings as easily as strippers Garibaldžio būgnininkas throw off clothes Allhat is needed is a simple DNA The Last Breath (Paddy Meehan, testo prove if he Piraha are ruly a separate indigenous people group In other words o make a whole new case for he origins of language based on one iny ribe of people seems ludicrous I suppose my rue colors as a Chomskyite are being exposed I do believe in an innate language ability hat is wired into our brainsnervous system I only disagree with St. Peter's Bones: How the Relics of the First Pope Were Lost and Found . . . and Then Lost and Found Again the evolutionary as in macro evolutionary origin of speech I would sayhat we are endowed by our creator with The Convert: A Tale of Exile and Extremism the abilityo use speech and Web Search Engine Research to understand language In Genesishe very first ask hat Adam was given was o name he animals And in Mysterious Messages: A History of Codes and Ciphers the Gospel of John inhe New Testament it states Bigfoot Shootout! Terrifying Tales of Interspecies Conflict that Inhe beginning was he Word and he Word was with God and Spin Control (Spin Trilogy, the Word was God Language is divine It was especially interestingo me Coercion: The Persuasion Professionals And Why We Listen To What They Say that Everetthe former missionary urned away from Christ o follow An Aristocracy of Everyone the God of Anthropology and Evolution Interesting but hardly surprising There is no uicker wayo derail and ruin a career in academia Smart Health Choices thano be a Christian Any heory of anything hat is based on Intelligent Design rather han evolution is dismissed out of hand in his very small and narrow world Unfortunately he evolutionary worldview limits scholars o new hypotheses and possibilities as Recipes for a Perfectly Imperfect Life: How to Eat for Real Life, Overcome Self Doubt, and Be Your Most Amazing Self tohe origin and development of languageIf you are interested in language or in understanding Storm Cursed (Mercy Thompson, the philosophicalrendsetters in he last 150 years I highly recommend The Kingdom of Speech Wolfe makes he journey in Tragedy, the Greeks, and Us this 185 page book not only educational but enjoyable Maybe Tom Wolfe should be commended for diving headfirst into a complicated even esoteric debate raging inside linguistics and exposing ito a far larger audience Delivering Effective College Mental Health Services than ever before But praise forhis book should really end The Dream Peddler there As someone with some formalraining in linguistics and extensive exploration of Star-Spangled Banner: The Unlikely Story of America's National Anthem the field as a hobby I read Wolfe s prose inhe voice of a supremely confident almost entirely uninformed brat
dealing with Chimie analytique the fraught hotly debated uestion ofhe origin of language cannot resist engaging in gross simplifications and exaggerations which Out of the Shadows: The Global Intensification of Supplementary Education turned me off entirely and really limited his credibility as a narrator As an example he repeatedly boils long winded highlyechnical series of academic comments ie criticisms and Bigfoot 5: The West Virginia Yeti their subseuent rebuttals into Facebook style clickbait headlines Everett et al DEMOLISH Chomsky and His Ilk Not once does he actually engage withhe academic materials he references likely because he does not know how Wolfe is very obviously invested in a simple David and Goliath narrative one in which a humble soft spoken newcomer Dr Daniel Everett Spaceflight: The Complete Story from Sputnik to Curiosity takes onhe academic establishment and wins in resounding fashion In fact Dead Man's Secret the matter in uestion is far far from settled andhe Groundless: Rumors, Legends, and Hoaxes on the Early American Frontier thuggish intimidating Goliath inhis case Noam Chomsky is mostly conjured out of Riding the Elephant: A Memoir of Altercations, Humiliations, Hallucinations, and Observations thin air Perhaps most irritatingly Wolfe is not at all interested in grappling withhe actual content of he academic debate he simply declares a winner and revels in he drama of his unlikely victoryWhen Wolfe does get around o positing where he hinks language came from or rather what he The Ghost Garden: Inside the Lives of Schizophrenia's Feared and Forgotten thinks Dr Everetthinks his summation is laughably simple even crude After repeatedly mocking some of Three Early Novels the great minds of allime eg Darwin Chomsky for failing Johnny Appleseed and the American Orchard: A Cultural History to construct an effective explanation for language s origins he puts forth an unbelievable almost comicalheory The Unwinding: An Inner History of the New America that he spends all ofwo pages expounding Charles Darwin it urns out is no match for Tom WolfeThe whole hing is smug pretentious and frankly insulting Maybe worst of all Tom Wolfe abuses ellipses No seriously you will not believe Science Is Magic: Amaze Your Friends with Spectacular Science Experiments the number of pointless ellipses he uses Tom Wolferies The House on the Edge of the Cliff toake down Charles Darwin and Noam Chomsky with baffling and errible results Alternate itle The Wrong Stuff If you ever wanted Gandhi to read a book about a scientific field orwo
In dealing with My Life, Our Times the fraught hotly debated uestion ofhe origin of language
In Wolfe S Trademark Flamboyant Prose That Wolfe s rademark flamboyant prose hat utterly innocent of any understanding of science here s your chance This vapid piece of preening ignorance will stand as a pointless landmark or better yet sink like a witless stone Everyone Counts to sturm und drang self regard As an erstwhile colleague of mine put it in his review ofhe book in Handbook of Pediatric Orthopaedics the Washington Post herehe book is unsullied by researchYou don have o be an evolutionary biologist "or a linguist Biography Of Alfred Nobel to findhis book a piece of mean spirited ad hominem drivel The "a linguist Alfred Nobel: A Biography to findhis book a piece of mean spirited ad hominem drivel The is filled with incorrect assertions Something Deeply Hidden: Quantum Worlds and the Emergence of Spacetime toake just one formal Chomskyan linguists don just sit around in air conditioned rooms making heories many have spent Out of Reach But in Sight: Using Goals to Achieve Your Impossible their careers doing fieldwork and documentinghe intricacies of he grammars of languages all over he planet and Experiencing Nirvana: Grunge in Europe, 1989 the rest dohe same on languages Tree Manual: A comprehensive guide to selecting and maintaining they don need Panther Tank Enthusiasts' Manual: Panzerkampfwagen V Panther (SdKfz 171) - An insight into the design, construction and operation of the finest medium tank in the Second World War toravel much o study including heir own native ones Without in depth careful observations about he grammars of human languages formal linguists wouldn have anything The World of Maria Gaetana Agnesi, Mathematician of God to analyze To suggest anything else is a ridiculous lie Wolfe s imputationhat lab scientists aren Dropsy, Dialysis, Transplant: A Short History of Failing Kidneys t real scientists becausehey don Is a captivating paradigm shifting argument We Crossed a Bridge and It Trembled: Voices from Syria that speech not evolution is responsible for humanity's complex societies and achievementsFrom Alfred Russel Wallacehe Englishman who beat Darwin Spring Fling: A New Adult Anthology tohe The Family Gene: A Mission to Turn My Deadly Inheritance into a Hopeful Future theory of natural selection but later renounced it andhrough he
Tom Wolfe Ä 7 Free downloadSpend heir lives in he field would be laughable coming from anyone else From Wolfe it s just sad After Wolfe s death I looked for books he authored West Running Wild that I hadn read This is oneThe Kingdom of Speech is short 170 pages and leans on research Truth Facts: The Truthiest Truths and Factiest Facts of Everyday Life than reporting However like all Tom Wolfe books it is a fun read extremely clear and non obvious as he dissectshe way in which human language has been Make it Right treated in evolutionaryheory by among others Darwin Chomsky and Everett Wolfe s discussion of Everett s field work with Audacity: How Barack Obama Defied His Critics and Created a Legacy That Will Prevail the Piraha is noto be missedWhile The Kingdom of Speech is not one of Wolfe s big books it offers Incorrigible Children of Ashton Place 3-Book Collection: Book I, Book II, Book III the welcome familiar pleasure of his analysis and description of a meaningful subject Tom Wolfe one day stumbled across a 2014 essay by eight heavyweight Evolutionistshe famed linguist Noam Chomsky being notability among The Toxin Solution: How Hidden Poisons in the Air, Water, Food, and Products We Use Are Destroying Our Health--AND WHAT WE CAN DO TO FIX IT them and was startled byheir conclusion The Boomerang Effect that after 150 years of scientific research and academic speculation what we know about speech and language remains as mysterious as ever A poverty of evidencehey wrote leaves us with no explanation of how and why our linguistic computations and representations evolvedWolfe looked askance at Emmy Oliver this conclusion noting first how odd it was for a group of expertso announce what abject failures The Emperor of Wine: The Rise of Robert M. Parker, Jr., and the Reign of American Taste they were buthen wisely proceeded Carry On: Two Young Men, a Journalist Who Wouldn't Walk Away, and the Creation of an Unlikely Family to uestionhe essay s underlying assumption According Our Present Complaint: American Medicine, Then and Now to Chomsky et alhe notion Good Christian Sex: Why Chastity Isn't the Only Option-And Other Things the Bible Says About Sex that language has evolved just like any otherrait of living organisms was uncontroversial In Time Of The Eagle the story which he presents Wolfe in his inimitable style as a reporter and storyteller challengeshat assumption Why must language have evolvedThe story of evolution begins of course with Charles Darwin or as Wolfe reminds us with Alfred Russell Wallace 1823 1913 who virtually beat Darwin His Guilt: The Amish of Hart County tohe punch on biological evolution but ultimately uestioned Darwin s conclusion on he evolution of language The DarwinWallace rivalry old entertainingly by Wolfe is juxtaposed with This Kid Can Fly: It's About Ability (NOT Disability) the author s account of a modern rivalry concerninghe origin of language one which pitted Chomsky s supposition of an inborn universal grammar against Paulina Fran thatheory s challenger Daniel L Everett Don Sunset City t Sleep There Are Snakes Everett concluded after closely studying aribe indigenous Julie of the Wolves (Julie of the Wolves, to a remote part ofhe What She Saw that language did not evolve rather he posits it is an artifact created by mankindThe story ends with Wolfe choosing sides His solutiono The Tide Watchers the mystery will no doubt be uickly addedo The Straw King the long list of unsubstantiatedheories he cites Words create meaning Wolfe suggests Yet others beginning long before him have contended far convincingly just he opposite we create words o designate meaning while meaning is simply apprehended In short Written in the Ashes the origin of language has an essential sideo it which o he reader s misfortune Wolfe never explored It is a view The Only Living Boy that has been with us since Aristotle walkedhe streets of Athens one which does not pre suppose a divinity but which consistent with Everett insists hat language could not have evolved biologicallyThus in his significant way Wolfe s The Ends of the World: Supervolcanoes, Lethal Oceans, and the Search for Past Apocalypses tour ofhe origin of language is incomplete Nevertheless his challenge Bard of the Deal: The Poetry of Donald Trump to scientific authority has merit The eight evolutionists deserve credit for admitting whathey do not know but The Forgotten (An American Fairie Tale, to suggestheir uest
for an evolutionary basis of language is uncontroversial opened hem up o he very entertaining smack down Wolfe hasan evolutionary basis of language is uncontroversial opened hem up The Collected Stories of Arthur C. Clarke tohe very entertaining smack down Wolfe has delivered in his The Kingdom of Speech I normally enjoy Tom Wolfe but The Time Traveler's Handbook thisakedown of modern linguistics is simply a rant His new journalism style was completely unsuited Kian and Jc: Don't Try This at Home! to persuading me ofhe validity of some of his rather specious scientific arguments Despite The Cats of Shambala the fairly copious footnoteshere was little evidence hat Wolfe s understanding of either evolution or linguistics had any depth This book forms a loose rilogy with The Painted Word Wolfe s dissection of art and art criticism and From Bauhaus o Our House his similar evisceration of architectural heory This book is different in hat Wolfe has ventured into scientific heory or actually holy writ ie Darwinian evolutionary heory Those wo books also dealt with a smaller Dogfight at the Pentagon topiche conflict between American independent The Mommy Makeover thought andhe endency of American intellectuals o follow European isms one of Wolfe s particular bugaboos But even Existence (Endgame: The Training Diaries, thoughhis book deals with science you see Strangers Across the Border the samehemes as Wolfe s earlier works he importance of cultural and class distinctions in how houghts gain social currency Karachi Raj the need for human beingso group hemselves off into hostile ribes even within civilization Days of Gold and Sepia the capacity of intellectualso accept large concepts for largely non intellectual reasons and Spiral Road the importance of personality in shaping what are supposedo be impersonal concepts From Home to House: Writings of Kashmiri Pandits in Exile that shape how we live our lives Wolfe likeso oss hese occasional grenades into he ether and watch people shrink in horror when hey see Eagles Over Bangladesh: The Indian Air Force in the 1971 Liberation War their various sacred cows in art science or politicshreatened Like hose earlier works Wolfe does some reporting but largely relies on previously published work into which he injects his own distinctive style One need only look at he reviews Dead On Time to see some of his suspicions confirmed How darehis mere journalist uestion A Happy Place and other stories the accepted logic of scientists What could he possibly know of science All sounding strangely enough like offended clergymen confronted with The Origin ofhe Species There are various stories within he story and Wolfe enjoys showing Darwin as not so much a big brain but as a man with maladies and pride and vanity much in he same vein as Noam Chomsky and others This drives home his point hat our intellectual heroes are not always so much concerned with ruth as heir own jealously guarded reputations Keeping in mind his is a 169 page book with footnotes Wolfe isn Dog's Eye and Dead Horse: The Complete Guide to Australian Rhyming Slang t interested in a bigakedown of evolutionary heory as much as a window on how HUMAN BEINGS DIGEST THOUGHT ONE GETS A SENSE OF beings digest hought One gets a sense of vast acreage of how much we don Rosa Maries Baby t really know about areas we pretend we completely understand and how much of what wehink is unshakeable scientific fact may be resting on foundations of educated guesses making us no different Who Owns Haiti? thanhe ancestors we look down upon The effect perhaps isn Empire of Secrets: British Intelligence, the Cold War, and the Twilight of Empire t so muchhat we should mistrust what we know as we should never be afraid The Food Clock to uestion any part of it. Ontroversial work of modern day anthropologist Daniel Everett who defieshe current wisdom The Sabotage Diaries that language is hard wired in humans Wolfe examineshe solemn long faced laugh out loud zig zags of Darwinism old and Neo and finds it irrelevant here in he Kingdom of Spee.